Add some kid-friendly fun to your next Halloween bash with these spooky peanut butter and jelly sand’witch’es. Made with nothing more than PB&Js, felt fabric and pipe cleaners, this is one tasty crafting project.

Peanut butter and jelly sand'witch'

peanut butter and jelly sand'witch' instructions


No ratings yet
Leave a Review

hat and legs

  • felt, black and green
  • pipe cleaners, orange
  • hot glue gun
  • glue sticks
  • scissors


  • white bread
  • peanut butter
  • jelly



  • Cut black felt into 2 circles (both 4.5" in diameter).
  • Cut slit to center of 1 circle.
  • Overlap slit edges to form hat top, secure seam with hot glue.
  • Glue top to center of other felt circle with hot glue.
  • Wrap pipe cleaner around the hat's base and trim, secure with hot glue.
  • Snip piece of pipe cleaner and fashion into a bow; secure to point of hat with hot glue.


  • Roll up 2 rectangles of felt, secure seam with hot glue.
  • Glue strips of black felt to legs.
  • Cut 2 pieces of black felt in shape of witch's shoes, glue together.


  • Cut small rectangle of green felt, fold rectangle in half lengthwise and cut small square out of rectangle.
  • Glue buckle pieces to the tops of the witch's shoes then glue to legs.


  • Trim crusts from bread, cut into 4" squares.
  • Spread one side with peanut butter, then jelly, top with a plain square.
  • Repeat for desired number of sand'witch'es.
  • Stack sand'witch'es on cake platter then top with hat, sticking 1 leg out of each side.


Adding just the smallest touches to simple, everyday foods makes all the difference in the world.
Tried this recipe?Mention @EverydayDishes or tag #everydaydishes!

Peanut butter and jelly sand'witch'